The Crimes of the Light-Fingered Clerk

Although Mrs Jane Carolan had not wanted to take a lodger, at least it was some comfort to her that the young man occupying a room in her house at 16 Union Road in Clapham was respectable. A solicitor’s clerk, he was always well-dressed and, if the large number of library books he borrowed was anything to go by, he seemed intent on self-improvement. At least he brought in some extra funds after what had been a very trying period for Mrs Carolan.

First her mother died. Shortly after, in May 1861, her husband was committed to the Camberwell Lunatic Asylum. He was a custom’s house clerk by the name of James Ward Carolan, and only seven months later he too died, leaving his wife £600 and two children to support — twelve-year-old Emma and nine-year-old James.

So it was with very great dismay that on Saturday 11 January 1862 Jane Carolan found Detective Sergeant White at her door. And her dismay turned to astonishment when the policeman demanded to see the lodger’s room.

Moxon smells a rat

On that same Saturday a young bookseller-librarian aged twenty-nine by the name of William Henry Moxon had been walking down Great Turnstile, a lane leading from Lincoln’s Inn Fields to High Holborn. He stopped outside No. 15, a second-hand bookshop lodged between a tobacconist and a pastry cook’s and run by one Richard Kimpton.

William could not help taking a professional interest in Kimpton’s stock as he had worked as a bookseller for twelve years, first in York and then in London at Bull’s Lending Library as head of the sales department. So it was with no little indignation that he saw that some of the books for sale were bound in the same distinctive bindings as all the Bull’s books. Even worse, the identifying numbers and labels had been removed. Quick as a flash Moxon ordered Kimpton to remove the books from sale, and he went to get the police.

The game is afoot

Richard Frederick Kimpton, who lived above the shop with his wife and seven children, was interviewed by a policeman. He explained that on Thursday 2 January he had received four books and a letter via the Parcels Delivery Company. The letter, from Mr Lionel R. J. Foster of Chertsey, offered him the books in exchange for three guineas. Kimpton thought this a little steep, so he said that he would take them for £2 15s. Foster agreed and asked Kimpton to pay by post.

After Moxon alerted him to the fraud, Detective Sergeant White took a train to Chertsey in order to interview Foster, making his first port of call the local Post Office to find out where his quarry lived. The post master explained that Foster had not yet moved into the district. In fact he had asked that any mail addressed to him be forwarded to the Post Office at 42 Long Acre in Covent Garden.

White immediately took the train back, arriving in Covent Garden in time to see a young man collect the mail for Lionel Foster at six in the evening. When challenged by White, the young man denied being Foster. However, he said that he was his friend, and that his name was Charles Story. On the way to the police station he was seen trying to throw away a letter from Bull’s asking him to return the library books.

Some serious reading

When the case came to court, the keen-eyed Yorkshireman William Henry Moxon explained that young Story had taken out a 15s. quarterly subscription to Bull’s Lending Library, which was just down from Cavendish Square at 19 Holes Street, where John Lewis is now. The subscription allowed Story to borrow six of the older books held by the library. He selected Ruskin’s The Seven Lamps of Architecture, the fourth and fifth volumes of the same writer’s Modern Painters, one of Paul Du Chaillu’s many books about exploration in Africa, The Ingoldsby Legends, and the first volume of Mrs Gaskell’s North and South.

If new, the books would have been worth £6, so a good deal of trust was involved in the transaction. The solicitor for the well-dressed young man tried to suggest that he had done nothing wrong as the books were not due to be returned. But it turned out that book theft was not Story’s only vice.

Duke of Herne Bay

On 9 November 1861 H. J. and D. Nicholls, tailors of 225 Regent Street, received an order in the post from E. Graham Duke, Esq., of Herne Bay in Kent. The discerning Mr Graham Duke sent his measurements and detailed instructions for clothes he wanted made: a beaver coat with a cape lined with quilted silk, a black superfine mourning coat, diagonal angola trousers and matching waistcoat and a waistcoat made of white marsala.

As the tailors did not have the quilted silk lining, they posted seven samples of available patterns to Herne Bay. Mr Graham Duke part paid for the clothes by sending half a £10 note — the other half literally to follow later — and a cheque for £3 7s. in the name of Edwin Browne. The remainder would be paid on receipt of the clothes.

The clothes were promptly parcelled up and sent by train to Sturry Station, a couple of miles outside Canterbury and near Herne Bay. But to the alarm of Messrs Nicholls and Nicholls information came from the bank that the cheque was a fake.

A treasure trove of evidence

Acting quickly, the Regent Street tailors sent a telegraph to the station master at Sturry, asking him to hold the parcel. Too late! A slim young man in an Inverness coat — a coat with a cape over the top reaching to the end of the sleeves, not to be confused with Sherlock Holmes’s favoured sleeveless Inverness cape — had already collected them. He had then proceeded to take the next train to London.

Back to Mrs Carolan’s house in suburban Clapham on 11 January 1862, conveniently close to the railway.

Searching the lodger’s room, Detective Sergeant White found a veritable treasure trove of evidence. There was correspondence from other subscription libraries, including Mudie’s and Hookham’s of Bond Street, to a Mr Villiers Villiers of Weybridge in Surrey. There was a letter addressed to the sartorially splendid E. Graham Duke in Herne Bay, helpfully redirected to the post office at 2 Greek Street in Soho, containing seven cloth samples from Nicholls as well as an optimistic invoice. And there were two coats, a pair of trousers and two waistcoats.

Whatever next?

Story was fortunate to be acquitted of defrauding Nicholls on a technicality, but he was found guilty of stealing library books from Bull’s and was sentenced to twelve months’ imprisonment. I am not sure what happened to him next.

If he actually was Charles J. A. Story, as is reported in the 1861 census, then he was the son of a solicitor and later emigrated to Australia, where he too worked as a solicitor, dying in 1880 at the age of thirty-seven. But given his propensity for adopting other names — Foster, Graham Duke, Villiers Villiers — who knows who he really was?

As for the other characters in this tale, Jane Carolan died only a few months later. Mr Kimpton had retired to Red Hill in Surrey by 1871, dying a year later at the early age of forty-six. William Henry Moxon started his own business near the Royal Docks in Plaistow, with his sister as assistant bookseller, and lived to about 1893.